I upgraded to the RAZR MAXX HD about a month ago - Love it. Once last month, I had an issue where I plugged the phone in at night, and it was off by morning. I was late for work (no alarm) and my Sgt. was not very happy. I did the reset (PWR + VOL DOWN) and the phone turned back on. It was fine for about 3 weeks, and this past week, it has done it every single night, and even during the day if I plug it in. I tried everything, safe mode, factory reset, soft resets. I am currently trying to do the battery calibration, but I contacted Verizon and they are sending me a refurb. (which I'm not happy about)
Did I make the right decision by saying the phone may just be defective?