An Accepted Solution is available for this post.

BlackBerry or iPhone

StreetDocRN
Champion - Level 1
‎01-11-2011 06:16 PM

Hi, all,

As most of you may know, Verizon Wireless has announced the release of the iPhone 4 for 2/10/11.  As a Blackberry owner and fan for over 4 years, I was curious of how many Blackberry owners would "jump ship" or "go to the dark side" of the iPhone.  My question to you is this, "Are you going to stay with the Blackberry or get an iPhone 4"?  I have to admit, it was a great deal for Verizon, as they will have the best of everything for the smartphone shopper.  From Android, to iPhone to Blackberry...they will have a great choice.  As a die-hard Blackberry fan, I am going to stick with my Bold for now, until a really great Blackberry device that tickles my fancy is released by Verizon.  Let me know how you feel.  Please comment...

Doc

Labels (1)
Labels
0 Likes
Reply
27 Replies
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
SoccerRef
Contributor - Level 3
‎01-11-2011 06:43 PM

Ahh the Great Question: iPhone or BB? My NE2 isn't up until Jul 3, 2012 so I have plenty of time decide. I love my BB Tour and evidently have to love it for the next 18 months. :smileyhappy: The poll at CB shows about 56% will stick with BB. In a business sense I think VZW has played it very smart with all the options; Droid, iPhone, BB. Personally I would have liked them to pick up the Torch or Style, both pretty cool BBs. So I defer my decision for 18 months, whether I want to or not.

 

P.S. If I had to choose RIGHT NOW I would probably go with a VZW Bold or jump to AT&T Torch.  :smileyhappy:

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
SydneyK
Master - Level 3
‎01-11-2011 08:36 PM

WHA?!?! Verizon's getting the iPhone???  :smileysurprised:

(I kid.)

 

I never say never, but I'm going to wait and see what RIM comes out with. I've tried every other smartphone platform, and BlackBerry just meets my needs best right now. Plus, I'm starting to feel like I'm over the days of paying $200-300 for a phone when most of my free time is spent doing stuff outdoors (I should probably own a Brigade).

 

I just hope RIM comes out with something soon ... I was really disappointed not to hear anything at CES.

 

What are YOUR thoughts on this topic, Doc?

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
StreetDocRN
Champion - Level 1
In response to SydneyK
‎01-11-2011 10:09 PM

Hey,

I figured any announcement for new devices would not happen.  It is all about the Playbook right now for RIM.  That was what CES was all about this year...the Playbook.  I am hoping some new devices are around the corner, though.  Hopefully soon, but I don't think Verizon would push any new Blackberry devices now since all of their marketing will be for pushing the iPhone.  But I can hope...

Doc

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
SydneyK
Master - Level 3
In response to SydneyK
‎01-12-2011 02:44 PM

Forgot to point out my BlackBerry helped me land several projects last year. Some clients email, asking if I want a project, and if the deadline is tight, they contact another freelancer if they don't hear back from me in an hour. Nothing beats push email and the obnoxiously noticeable flashing LED on BlackBerry!

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
FuzzyB
Newbie
In response to SydneyK
‎01-16-2011 01:16 AM

I concur on this...I also have landed numerous accounts because of the speed and reliability of my BB.  Iphone, droid, berry...they are all very nice devices.  But if you're looking for a tool first and media device second, berry all the way.  In fact, out of the 3, the iphone is the last one I would choose...at least from a middle aged businessman's point of view :smileyhappy:

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
RCA
Newbie
In response to FuzzyB
‎01-16-2011 06:43 AM

You're welcome Doc.

FuzzyB wrote:

 

 But if you're looking for a tool first and media device second, berry all the way.

That's right, and that's what it comes down to for me.

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
cjsmoove
Newbie
In response to RCA
‎01-19-2011 04:20 PM

Is'nt Iphone 5 coming in the summer ??

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
Spiral
Master - Level 1
In response to cjsmoove
‎01-19-2011 04:31 PM

 

cjsmoove wrote:

Is'nt Iphone 5 coming in the summer ??

That is pure speculation.  Many are saying it will not come to Verizon until at least 2012.

 

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
lou61166
Contributor - Level 1
In response to Spiral
‎01-21-2011 04:15 PM

I agree about the buisness side of a blackberry,but that is it,for using a mobile phone for web browsing,music and media,and apps,the iphone blows away blackberry.not mention when a new os is released the iphone can get it,not all Blackberries can do this.i have a Blackberry for phone and text,and a ipod touch 4 generation,for everything else.it all depends on what you need a mobile device to do.

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
SydneyK
Master - Level 3
In response to lou61166
‎01-21-2011 04:23 PM

 

lou61166 wrote:

i have a Blackberry for phone and text,and a ipod touch 4 generation,for everything else.

This -- like my BB and iPad -- is a perfect combination!

 

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
LCromwell
Specialist - Level 1
‎01-11-2011 11:11 PM
I had the I-Phone VS BB explained as follows: I-Phone can only have 1 app at a time. My computer has been down for over 2 weeks so everything from checking my emails to on line buying of new computer parts has been difficult but manageable. The I-Phone would be even harder,not to mention no battery to be able to swap out. I have never had AT&T cell service so I cannot comment. The reports I have read on BB new releases from BB Pres. Is no new phones for maybe 10 Yrs. He seems to think that technology will not be able to keep up to produce what he calls the Super Phones. If this is really how he think BB's days are numbered. I happen to like my Storms 1 and now 2. I was hoping for a S3 this summer running OS 6. That may not happen now. As for me BB is an adult business phone.
0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
SuzyQ
Community Leader
Community Leader
‎01-12-2011 12:37 AM

 

StreetDocRN wrote:

Hi, all,

... My question to you is this, "Are you going to stay with the Blackberry or get an iPhone 4"? ... Let me know how you feel.  Please comment...

Doc

 

For me, this is a no brainer, since I am not an "official" Blackberry user yet (soon . . . like tomorrow!) , but thought long and hard about jumping into the world of Blackberry, I'm staying with BB.  LCromwell said it's an adult business phone, and that's exactly how I intend to use it.  Well said!

 

My son (25) has had the iPhone since it's debut on AT&T, and had the iPhone4 the day it was released - so I've seen it, and watched him play with it.  It does do some fun stuff, and it's like his computer, phone, communication tool, and gaming gadget with him and active at all times.  Works great for a 25 year old!

 

I need my email, and client communications - and I plan to use it to view websites on a mobile device so I can better design sites for mobile viewing and use.  Networking, email, and work - I think a BB will be a better fit for me than the iPhone.

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
StreetDocRN
Champion - Level 1
In response to SuzyQ
‎01-12-2011 05:26 AM

Hi,

Great comments from all, especially LCromwell.  I forgot until he reminded us the iPhone has a battery that can not be easily replaced, whereas the Blackberry does.  Keep the comments coming and thanks to all.

Doc

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
needaiphonenow
Newbie
‎01-12-2011 07:52 AM

You don't know how long I have been waiting for this day.  Yes, I will go from my blackberry touch to the verizon iphone.  I really have not been happy with the blackberry touch for a variety of reasons but got stuck with a contract and I did not want to go the AT&T.  

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
carey
Newbie
‎01-13-2011 04:21 PM

Thanks Doc for starting this topic.  I too can't decide.  I have the BB Tour 9630 and do love it except for the trackball!  I'm due for an early upgrade now.  I have the iPad and love that too!  Will the iPhone download webpages at the same speed of the BB?  I don't use my BB for work, although I do love getting my emails on my phone.  Although, mine do take time to come thru to my phone once it hits my inbox.  Would love some feedback.

 

Thanks!!

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
RCA
Newbie
In response to carey
‎01-15-2011 08:00 AM

I've been a BlackBerry user for about four or five years now. I must say it's tempting but what it comes down to is this:

  1. I need a phone that can sync to Outlook (Contacts, Calendar and Notes).

  2. I must be able to easily operate my phone with one hand. I see a colleague answering his iPhone and he has to swipe his finger across the screen to answer and hang up. Really?

  3. I need the ability to quickly view and send email, even with one hand on occasion. It's going to be tough to beat holster mode.

  4. Good sound quality while on a voice call. Both speakerphone and earpiece.

  5. Tether phone to laptop for occasional internet access while I'm out in the field.

There's no doubt about it that the iPhone is very attractive. I'm pretty sure from what I understand that it can sync to outlook but I heard it was only Calendar and Contacts, no biggie. I take the BlackBerry a step further and have only work Contacts, Calendar and Notes sync to my work PC. At home, only my personal info will sync. I achieve this by using the Filters in Desktop Manager. I wonder if the iPhone has this ability?

Using the iPhone with one hand will definitely take some practice. I don't think I would ever get used to it but who knows.

Email on the BlackBerry is top notch. I see my colleague on his iPhone viewing his emails with no real problems but it does take him some extra steps to get there. He does say it sometimes takes a long time to send. Nothing beats the BB when you hear your email notification and you simply pull the BB out of the holster and presto, there's your email ready for viewing.

The sound quality on the iPhone will be interesting now that it's on a CDMA network. Hopefully it will sound decent. There has been a lot of talk about sound quality and dropped calls on the iPhone. Some say it's the at&t network, some say it's the iPhone and some say it's both.

I'm pretty sure from what I have read that the iPhone will have the ability to tether and if I'm not mistaken it can be used as a WiFi Hotspot?

If I was to switch it wouldn't be with this version only having 3G. I would wait for a 4G version to come out. For now, I'm sticking with BlackBerry

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
StreetDocRN
Champion - Level 1
In response to RCA
‎01-15-2011 09:17 PM

Hi,

Thanks, RCA for bringing out those points.  Thanks for sharing your ideas and opinions of the Blackberry Vs the iPhone. 

Doc

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
wyliec2
Enthusiast - Level 2
In response to RCA
‎01-22-2011 05:54 PM

Seems as though very few people use BB Desktop Manager - my phone would be useless without the ability to filter messages - I have 25 layers of filters and another set that I use for vacation.  I am committed to the BlackBerry and am not considering any other device.  I have been eligible for an upgrade for nearly a year now but Verizon doesn't seem to be as interested in new BB devices(ie. Torch) as new device platforms.  In my circumstance its more a situation of having to consider switching carriers instead of platforms....  :smileymad:

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
LCromwell
Specialist - Level 1
In response to wyliec2
‎01-22-2011 06:39 PM

I think I understand what you are saying about email filters, but where within the BB can you set these fillters and what kinds of email filters are you telling the BB to do?

0 Likes
Reply
An Accepted Solution is available for this post.
tootygreen
Newbie
‎01-22-2011 02:05 AM

The app appeal of the iPhone caught my eye for a long time, but I really love my BB, and now the Droid has me curious too.  My Curve 8330 is a bit outdated compared to everything that came out immediately after I was in a 2-yr contract, but it still really meets all my needs.  I'm either going to upgrade to a more sophisticated BB, or possibly a Droid.  I'm still undecided, so I'll watch the forum closely to get some more input. 

 

A coworker told me VZW is doing away with the NE2 right before the iPhone comes up for purchase, so if anyone's heard anything to confirm or deny this, I'd be interested to know if that's accurate for all upgrades, or just toward the iP4, or just crap.

0 Likes
Reply