Why Buy A Droid over an IPhone

[GASA765]

My wife and I are currently Verizon customers and are looking to upgrade our phones. We've looked at the Droid and the IPhone and had a demonstration on both. I've seen a professional comparison at PhoneDog.com, but want to know from real users why we should upgrade to a Droid instead of an IPhone? We realize Verizon has less issues with dropped calls etc, but from what I've read here there are still a lot of problems with Droid's, and I think a lot of that may be because it's still so new and not all of the kinks have been worked out.

My wife wants a phone that's fairly easy to use out of the box.

So, we're not trying to start a war, but want opinions of people that have compared both and picked the Droid over the IPhone and why they chose Droid.

Thanks

[docfreed]

Number One Reason is the high quality of the Verizon network - the only time I get dropped calls is when I'm talking to one of my friends with an IPhone.  After all, the purpose of the phone is to make/receive calls - all the rest is fluff. A close second is the open nature of the OS and the friendliness of the Droid - The out of box user experience is very high and the phone is very sturdy. And don't be fooled by the Apple App Store - there are thousands of free Android apps also.

[bob88884]

You are kidding about no dropped calls right?

I have dropped so many calls since I went with Verizon it's unreal, I should have never left T-Mobile

[somegirl]

Two words: Open Source

[truelove79]

1) Verizon's network - seriously it rocks.  No, it's not perfect.  But it really is the best.  Their customer service and website, not so much.

2) MULTITASKING!!!!!!!!!  Seriously, this is HUGE!!!!!!  You can do all sorts of things on an android phone all at the same time.  Listen to music, edit a document and get updates on sports scores at the same time.

3) Widgets.  I don't think the iPhone OS allows widgets on their home pages correct?  This is huge for me.  No need to actually open an app to get a summary of information.  For instance you can have weather widgets, sports scores widgets, photo widgets, mail widgets, etc. etc.

Android is very young so no, it's not as polished as the iPhone and there are surely more hiccups and bugs as the android has to support MANY different hardware platforms, but as it ages it's going to get better and better.

[jayjay1122]

Network, network, network!

The Verizon commercials about maps, as silly as it sounds, are true!

The bottom line here is that unless you live along Northeast coast, Florida, Texas or California, you are unlikely to get reliable 3G service if at all on AT&T.

Unfortunately, I must carry around an AT&T Blackberry for work in addition to my personal Verizon phone and the differences in 3G coverage are stunning. I am working in  PA for a few months and I cannot drive 15 miles in any direction and maintain 3G coverage on my Blackberry running on AT&T. As a matter of fact, the area I am in JUST got 3G 5 months ago and I am 40 miles from Philly, not in the mountains of West Virginia!

[supitsmike]

---

jayjay1122 wrote:

Network, network, network!

The Verizon commercials about maps, as silly as it sounds, are true!

---

Out of everything, I want to agree with these two sentences the most. A phone is only as good as it's network. I strongly believe that. On the flipside though, it depends on what you want your phone to do...

I've had both the iPhone 3GS and all Android phones (Aside from the Nexus and Behold II...yuck). I may be biased, but I really can't stand the small sandbox that Apple places people with iPhone's in. Don't get me wrong, I have said it many times before on this board, the iPhone is a good piece of hardware. But there's something to be said about an Open Source (a nod to somegirl) system that just kind of grabs people, and it's a difficult clutch to get out of.

You see, Android gives people the freedom to do pretty much anything they want with their phones. That goes true for any providider/manufaturer/developer that gets their hands on Android. I enjoy the fact that I have the freedom to do anything I want with my phone. I like having the freedom to use third party programs, not being tied down to just iTunes, or anything Apple branded. I love the fact that Android allows developers to create whatever they want -- they don't tell developers "No you can't put that on the market" (Apple, I already have parents thank you very much). I like the way I can change the face of Android at any time. With Android, you can make it personal, partial to you. With the iPhone OS, its like you're playing with a doll that tells you what to and not do to it.

Android is still very much in it's early stage. But I can tell you that it's nothing like the way it was back when the G1 Was first released. The rapid growth is startling, it's burgeoning and garnering so much attention it's silly.

Android devices do pretty much anything that the iPhone can do, if not, more.

But at the end of the day, it's what YOU want, and what fits YOUR needs.

Cheers!

Mike

[JWS1956]

---

 not in the mountains of West Virginia!

---

I live in West Virgina and my job carries me all throughout the eastern states.  I am here to say.  No much of anything works in the mountains of West Virginia.  How ever, I have the HTC Eris and except for the programming issues, I am very pleased with it.  Where I have been and had no coverage, other phones didn't have any either.  And as far as 3G.  Verizon has it way over AT&T here in West Virginia.  I have been to Beckley which Verizon has 3G and AT&T doesn't.  Beckely is a pretty good sized city for West Virginia.  As far as ease of use.  I am not a computer expert by any means, but if the iPhone is easier than the Eris, it must be something a child could use. 

[jayjay1122]

I live in West Virgina and my job carries me all throughout the eastern states.  I am here to say.  No much of anything works in the mountains of West Virginia.  How ever, I have the HTC Eris and except for the programming issues, I am very pleased with it.  Where I have been and had no coverage, other phones didn't have any either.  And as far as 3G.  Verizon has it way over AT&T here in West Virginia.  I have been to Beckley which Verizon has 3G and AT&T doesn't.  Beckely is a pretty good sized city for West Virginia.  As far as ease of use.  I am not a computer expert by any means, but if the iPhone is easier than the Eris, it must be something a child could use. 

---

To reiterate this point travel 30 miles further west of Beckely and AT&T completely goes away! Forget 3G, forget EDGE, you can even forget GSM! That's right, NO SERVICE AT ALL!! I spent the last week a couple of miles west of Lewisburg (Rupert UGH) and my ERIS had 3G coverage up a mountain and my AT&T Blackberry Bold had a nice pretty X where the antenna should be.

This also goes to the point another poster made further back, yes if you live in one of the 5 metro areas that has strong 3G the Iphone may be great for you, but typically leaving a "metro area" means leaving 3G and in some cases even EDGE behind rendering your Iphone nothing more than a very expensive IPOD that you can make calls on!!

Those **bleep** AT&T commercials talk about surfing and checking email while you are talking on the phone...REALLY?!?!...I've been a network engineer for 15 years and I travel 2 weeks a month and have a staff of 6 that report to me and I have NEVER, not one time EVER checked an email or surfed the web while talking on the phone!!

Ok, I'll calm down now!!

[bkfist]

To be honest there are not that many "kinks" still to work out on the Motorola Droid. Many revolve around trying to get access to "non-compliant" pop3 email. (AOL, Yahoo etc.) For me, the main reason I would never consider the iphone is that I do not want to be told what I can do with my phone, what program i can install, how I must dial with it, how it must look. Android Market is not the only "approved" source for programs on any Android device. There are alternative "Markets" if you wish to install an application, and any program can be installed OTA by simply downloading the APK file and selecting it to install. Nobody is ever going to be able to limit or control what applications you may run on your Android device. If you are at all interested in "streaming media" such as watching videos online, keep in mind that the apple restraints on the kinds of programs that can be put in their app store will prevent Adobe Flash from ever being installed on the iphone, as Flash is an "interpretive language" and is prohibited. People wishing to "publish" a flash application or such for an iphone would have to create a separate "app" for each, which of course will allow tens or hundreds of thousands of separate apps to be added to the itunes store, each providing a single function, show, etc. while on an Android device you would simply be able to use your web browser to access each of these items without having to download an app to do so. (Flash is not YET available on Android either, as Adobe has not released it, but it is expected in the next several weeks.)

[stevehy]

I have a Moto Droid and really like it. I also have 2 iPhones (wife and daughter). I also purchased the iPhone the day it came out 2 years ago. You said your wife is looking for a device that is easy to use. Hands down, get an iPhone. It is the device I recommended to my wife when she wanted a phone, and she has learned to use many of the features of the phone because it is so logical. The iPhone is a truly polished device with really no rough edges, and in 2 years never really had problems with voice calls (the network is not as problem plagued as some would have you believe). 

Another respondent said it’s a phone (Droid and iPhone) and the primary purpose is making calls; not correct. These are small handheld computers and for non technical users, iPhone must be the device.

I am a software developer and the Droid is perfect for me, but it is not really as logical to use and polished as the iPhone (perfect for me but not for many users). I can see where this could be confusing to some. The Android OS has a way to go before it will have true mass appeal. Additionally, the Apple ecosystem is best set up to handle users like you wife(regular users) and they do an amazing job at support; something that Google, Motorola and Verizon really can’t and aren’t prepared to do.

Both of the OS’s are based on Unix variants, but the iPhone has years of fine tuning advantage over Google. 

Lastly, the Apple app store is amazing, whereas the Google marketplace is good but not in the same universe.

Having said all this, I would buy a Droid again (in a heartbeat) as it’s really a very powerful device, but it reminds me of a Windows computer in its immature state and as a result is more difficult to use than an iPhone, which is really very easy.

Sorry for the long winded reply and I hope this helps you.

Steve 

[jsh1120]

There isn't a single point I'd dispute in Stevehy's post above.

And while there's little doubt that Verizon's overall network is superior to AT&T's, it's also worth noting that if you use your phone 99% of the time where AT&T has good coverage, the fact that you can get great 3G coverage in rural Montana on Verizon but not on AT&T is irrelevant.

I wouldn't give up my Droid for anything else out there. But I, too, am a software developer and I'm perfectly willing to deal with the immaturity of the Android platform and marketplace. If my top priority were high quality business support, I'd have a Windows Mobile phone or a BlackBerry. If easy access to every consumer app were my highest priority I'd have an iPhone. And if it bothered me to update a dozen apps a week on my phone (as it would my wife), I wouldn't have a Droid.

As it is, my Droid meets my business needs (mostly) and provides all the toys I care to use. (But I'm not a single 20-something, much less a teenager who has to worry about exceeding 500 text messages a month. And I don't play games on my phone.)  In addition, it's a device whose potential is considerably greater, imo, than devices on any other platform. And I value that.

Now if I could just find an application that splits the dinner bill unequally among six or more diners, I'd be a completely happy camper. (There are at least half a dozen apps that provide that functionality on the iPhone and they're easily found for both WM and BB devices.)

[fezzik]

Yes it is true Apple has a year up on Android in cell phone operating system building.  And because they are a marketing giant they have more apps and I suppose to some more importantly more games and silly content.  The interesting thing is Android is and will be more compatible with more outside devices and software.  My Droid opperates very much how I would expect a Linux phone to operate except I don't have a terminal to work with.  Because of that I imagine it is more user friendly than what I would want from a Linux based phone. 

Now as to which is easier to use and functions better that is personal preference.  I hate the iPhone.  I have tried to use it, tried to figure it out and it just seems anti-intuitive to me.  I have a hard time with it.  The Droid just makes sense to me.  I picked it up and knew how to use it.  For me it was what I wanted/expected from a smartphone.  Any issues I have had have been so minor none come to mind and are nothing I wouldn't expect from a phone.  Some people swear by the iPhone and can't stand the Droid they are generally die hard AT&T customers and pop culture lemmings.  It must be the best because everyone has one and look at the schnazy ad campaign.  I respect the iPhone for what it did in opening up the networks to smarter smartphones but it isn't for me. 

Honestly the AT&T network is top of the line.  The fact that there are holes in the 3G coverage isn't an issue because Edge is ok for most uses.  In this big war what Verizon isn't telling everyone is that for what 99% of us use our phones for Edge has fine speed.  What AT&T doesn't tell you is you can only use data and voice at the same time in areas with 3G coverage.  The reality is the advantages to the AT&T network (and there are some they are faster and they do have simultaneous data and voice capabilities) are only in the little blue spots, and the advantages to the Verizon network is they have high speed 3G coverage in more of the country.  There are places where you can only get AT&T and there are places where you can only get Verizon both are quite capable.  Now what no one is telling you is that the majority of the problems people are having with AT&T network are actually iPhone problems.  There is a design flaw that makes the iPhone slower and less reliable.  Now AT&T does have more dropped calls than Verizon and even in my area where there is great coverage there are dead spots where your call will go out every time and you just either need to not be on the phone when you drive through there or be prepared to call back when you get through it.  Verizon doesn't seem to have those here. 

Now my wife says that the best phone she has played with and used is her Blackberry Curve 8530 on Verizon.  Aside from the occasional e-mail outages it is the greatest thing since sliced bread to her.  I personally can't use it for much.  My next phone will probably be something like the Nexus 1 or the next generation or whatever is the best touch phone available in mid-2011. I almost never use the hardware keypad.  So it really comes down to personal preference.  iPhone 3Gs and Droid are pretty comperable.  Best I can tell iPhone 3G and Droid Eris are close I believe.  Though I think the Eris wins hands down in that comparison.

[sigmunddroid]

Droid is just better just compair the maps of the two phones att just sucks

[pinkster]

The blackberry is about the poorest excuse for a phone that anyone can think of. There are so many duplication of things on the screen that it is pitiful. I mean what is application, downloads, games, etc on the screen. Please I am ready to throw mine against the wall. The IPhone is one of the most intuitive phones there is. If you don't think so then you are more a PC user then mac user.

Now if you are talking about closed in Verizon is one of the BIGGEST closed systems there is. Why do you think they turned down IPhone to begin with? They did not want to use ITunes. Verizon is who Apple went to in the first place. 

I have friends in Motorola and even they say competing with the IPhone is difficult. Noone can beat Apples touch screen and

Apple is way ahead of the game with apps. Let's face it we can talk open systems, we can say apps are **bleep** but for many, apps is where it is at for many people! And how many people have Ipods... so it is  a natural transition.

I live in a very dense area of Florida where the reception should be very good for Verizon and I am 1/4 mile from a VZW tower.

By the tower I have 5 bars, by my house 2 bars... hello VZW tune your radios!  I have even called and put in a trouble ticket.

Yes VZW has a great footprint. AT&T needs to improve its footprint. AT&T is GSM, VZW is CDMA. 

I can't even use the internet connection on my Blackberry, it is soooo slow.  I live by water and bridges, I get a lot of dropped calls.

It all depends on where you live. 

Will Verizon get the IPhone, I doubt it. They are pretty stubborn about moving away from their closed system 

The one thing you can't argue is the popularity of the IPhone. If Verizon does not get it the I am leaving. At&t has a really good footprint where I live...

As far as the Droid, I don't want a keyboard.

[whit66]

I noticed you mentioned about downloading apps on  a weekly basis, are you implying that if you buy the Moto Droid you will have to download apps?

[#17]

You don't have to, but why wouldn't you?  There are a lot of nice apps out there.  It would be like buying a new computer and never buying any software for it.

[TheGreatOne]

---

jimfitzgerald wrote:

You don't have to, but why wouldn't you?  There are a lot of nice apps out there.  It would be like buying a new computer and never buying any software for it.

---

Agreed there are a lot of nice apps out there that deserve the money. At first I wouldn't spend any money on any of the apps. When one of my favoriate game came to the market (Diner Dash 2) you had to pay for it, so I forked over $2 & paid for it. I also bought What The Doodle! recently. Worth the money.

[#19]

I have a bunch of apps, but I've only paid for 2 or 3.

[kneffscribe]

Right now I am wishing I bought the iphone.  The simple functions....call, text, re-dial (even lock, with that microscopic button on the top right) are totally frustrating me.  I feel like my phone is too smart for me...grr. 

Can you advise on these simple functions...my Voyager was so much better in these simple commands.  Thanks.

[sranger]

Both are hig quality phones...

So basically you have to ask your self this question;

A) Do you prefer a safe experiance where someone tells you how your phone should  look and operate and makes all importiant decisions for you.  All possible software for the phone is approved or denyed by a single company (and is subject  to it's whims).  All content for your phone will comple from one company and must be purchsed from that company.

or

B) You prefer to make your own decisions ( right or wrong)  and you like having an entire comunity of people developing applications in a free and open fourm for your phone.   They allow you to make desicions about what your home screen should look like.  You can buy content from many sources and easly sync your phone with many different software and platfroms.  

If you are Type A, get an iPhone.  If you are a type B get a Droid.......

On a technical note.  The screen on the Droid is far bettter....