I got the body glove. While it lets you grip the phone better it's very hard to hit the buttons on the sides and will not allow you to use a dock...
I will be trying to return mine.
I got the black body glove today at the Verizon store. I was told before I got it that it would not work with the docks. I liked the feel of it and there's not a lot of cases available anyway's so I got it. I really like it a lot. Haven't had any problems, yet, with the buttons.
I have the same problem with the skin. My rep did not tell me it would not work with dock. Will be "trying" to return it Monday. It is a great phone. really happy with it.
The main problem is with the most important button being the one that puts the device to sleep and turns wakes it up - very hard to press with the protector.
And also I like it without better anyway - only reason I bought one was because everyone else was... figured better safe than sorry but after I thought of the number of times I dropped my blackberry I really don't need it.