I just got my replacement phone about four hours ago and I ended up getting a phone that is not "Like New". I already called Verizon and I will be getting another re-replacement as soon as I send off and they receive my original phone. So heads up, check your device if you get a replacement and call Verizon immediatelly if there is a problem with your "Like New" replacement.
Here are a few photos I managed to take with my wife's iphone. You can clearly see a "smudge" on the phone.
Droid X
Droid X
Droid X