I have had an OtterBox Defender for quite some time, since I got the G2 in Feb 2014 at a corporate store. I have the white G2 and originally got the black OBDefender since it was all they had. After the tab slots broke in a couple spots on the faceplate portion I had it replaced...but OB sent me a sprint/ATT version...2 times in a row. Finally I got OB to send me the right case and they asked me if I wanted the glacier/white version. This one looks a lot better, but now it is in the same shape as the other one, in fact the rubber is stretching on the back now. I have had 1 black, one white, and 2 sent that were not for the Verizon variant. What has been your luck so far? I know I won't buy another Verizon exclusive of a phone that is carried on all major carriers again. i really wanted the Commuter, but you know how it goes when one carrier decides to change one thing about a phone that the other carriers don't change. Makes it really hard to search with confidence on Amazon and eBay when all the sellers say, "Fits ALL carriers."
I have the defender on my G2 and hate it . Dirt gets under the screen easily. After about a month of use the rubber stretches and doesn't latch/hook on the cover well. Not a good case for long term usage. Currently looking at a cheap knock off case with a rubber/plastic protective coating. I'm done with the Otter brand -too many issues for too long .